Business · Library

Why Do You Keep Hiring People You Stop Trusting?

When authority contracts every time a strong executive decides differently.

It usually starts well. You hire someone senior enough to own real decisions. You tell them you want initiative, judgment, and independence.

Then they make a decision you would not have made.

The contraction of authority

The first disagreement is easy to tolerate. The next one matters more. You ask more questions. You check the work. You become more involved because the stakes are high and your experience is relevant.

Nothing about that move is irrational.

But the executive learns. Important decisions are safer when the founder is involved. Soon the founder is seeing more drafts, joining more meetings, and becoming the escalation point again.

Then he looks at the executive and sees exactly what he did not want: another person waiting for instructions.

The executive becomes more dependent at the same time the founder becomes less trusting.

The hiring problem may be real

Sometimes you picked the wrong person. Senior hires fail. Capability matters. Trust should not be unconditional. A weak executive does not become strong because the founder learns to let go.

The diagnostic question is whether the same failure pattern survives changes in people. Third COO. Same problem. Fourth search. Same shape.

If that is happening, the unit of analysis has to widen.

Define what authority means before the next hire

Which decisions are genuinely delegated? What information does the founder need without becoming the decision-maker again? What happens when the executive's call is reasonable but different? What evidence justifies restoring founder command? How will both people know whether the problem is capability, governance, trust, or simply disagreement?

Those distinctions matter because “I don't trust him” can describe several completely different situations. The executive may lack judgment. The founder may be receiving filtered information. The role may be poorly designed. The founder may have delegated responsibility without transferring authority. Or the relationship may have reached a point where neither man can interpret the other's actions cleanly.

Before another search begins, locate exactly what keeps failing. Otherwise a new executive enters an old operating system and eventually produces an old result.